Support

Answers to the questions people ask most. Still stuck? Write to us.

Set up your first box

A new BentoSort starts with one example tray, “Everyday”: four boxes for Desktop, Downloads, Documents and the Trash.

  1. Click the Desktop, Downloads or Documents box, or drop a file on it. The folder panel opens already pointed at that folder. Click Choose. From now on the box can reach that folder.
  2. To change a box, hover over it and click its gear. The box settings start with the target: a folder, Photos, a share service, tags only, the Trash, or an app. Below it: name, icon, colors, and the rules (mode, name clash, date subfolders, tags). To use your own picture as the icon, pick Picture, then click Choose Picture… or drop a picture on the square beside it. For a logo on a plain background, Remove Background makes that background transparent.
  3. To add a box, click an empty cell with the faint +. To change the grid, click the Grid button in the toolbar and pick the size in the field of 8 by 8 cells; the title shows it, for example “4 × 3 Tray” (columns × rows), and says what a smaller grid would do: a box that spans several cells shrinks to the cells that remain (“1 box will shrink”), and a box whose top-left cell falls outside is hidden (“2 boxes will be hidden”). When the grid grows again, hidden boxes come back and shrunk boxes grow back to their own size as far as cells are free. To move, resize or delete boxes, switch on Edit Mode (⌘E): drag a box to move it, drag the white arc at its bottom-right corner to give it more or fewer cells (that becomes its own size), and click the minus at its top left to delete it.

Help ▸ Show Introduction brings back the short welcome sheet.

Video: first steps

A short video tour: your first tray, adding boxes, dropping files, Move or Copy, undo and the drop log.

Playing loads the video from YouTube (youtube-nocookie.com), and Google’s privacy policy applies. More in our privacy policy.

Questions

Does a box move or copy?

Each box has its own mode, Move or Copy, in its settings (Move is the default; Settings › New Boxes changes the default for new boxes). With no key held, the box’s mode decides. To copy just this once, hold ⌥ while you drop; to move, hold ⌘. Holding both is the same as holding neither. While you drag, the box shows what it will do and follows the keys as you press them, for example “Move to Receipts”, or “Copy to Receipts” while ⌥ is held (Settings › Dropping can hide this label).

Items dragged from Mail, Safari or Photos are always copied, even onto a Move box and even with ⌘: the app they came from keeps its own, and the label says “Copy to …”. Trash, tags-only and Open With App boxes take only files that are already on your Mac.

Some targets have a fixed way of working: the Trash always moves to the Trash, share services and Open With App boxes leave the original where it is, and a tags-only box leaves the item where it is and only adds tags. On these boxes, ⌥ and ⌘ change nothing.

Is a move safe? What if something goes wrong halfway?

Within one disk, BentoSort moves an item with a simple rename when macOS lets it change the folder the item came from. When it may not (an app from the Mac App Store reaches only what you give it), and between disks (for example onto an external drive or a NAS), BentoSort copies each item, checks that every file arrived with the same size, and only then deletes the original. If the copy fails or you cancel, the partial copy is removed and the original stays untouched.

If a copy succeeded but the original could not be removed, the drop summary says so for that file (“Copied, but could not remove the original”) and both copies exist. Nothing is deleted silently.

Can I stop a long drop?

When a drop takes more than a second, the box shows a progress bar with a Cancel button. The Dock icon shows the bar too once the size of the drop is known.

  • A folder drop stops before anything is placed: partial copies are removed and the box says “Cancelled. Nothing was changed.”
  • A very large drop runs in portions. Cancel stops it in the current portion; what the portions before it placed stays (see the next question).
  • A Photos, Trash or tags-only drop stops before the next item. The item in progress finishes, and the box says what was done, for example “Stopped: 3 of 10 items done. The rest were left alone.” What was done can be undone as usual, except in Photos.
  • Share and Open With App boxes hand everything over in one step, so they show no Cancel.
Is there a limit to how many files I can drop?

Not on folder, Photos, Trash and tags-only boxes. macOS gives an app from the Mac App Store access to each file you drag onto it, and only to so many at a time. BentoSort hands that access back when it no longer needs it, so you can sort tens of thousands of files in one session.

One very large drag (more than about 700 to 1,700 files at once, depending on how long their paths are) works too. BentoSort pauses when you drop it (about seven seconds for ten thousand files), then places the files in portions under one progress bar. Cancel stops it in the current portion; what the portions before it placed stays, and the box says what was done, for example “Stopped: 3 of 10 items done. The rest were left alone.”

Copies from such a drop can be undone: they go to the Trash. A move, a Trash drop or a tags-only drop of that size cannot. Share and Open With App boxes don’t take it and say “Too many items for one drop on this box. Drop fewer at a time.”

To stay within the limit, BentoSort lets go of the oldest drops first: once the drops that can still be undone add up to about that many files, the oldest moves, Trash drops and tags-only drops lose their Undo, as they do when BentoSort quits. Copies to a folder keep theirs.

How do I undo a drop?

Click the Undo button in the toolbar, or press ⌘Z or choose Edit ▸ Undo while a BentoSort window is in front. Right after you drop from Finder, Finder is still the active app and gets the ⌘Z; click the button, or click the BentoSort window first. Its tooltip names the drop, for example “Undo Move to Receipts”. Press it again to undo the drop before, one at a time.

Each tray has its own history, and it lives in memory: when BentoSort quits, the history is gone.

  • Moved items go back to where they came from.
  • Copies go to the Trash.
  • A file that a drop replaced comes back from the Trash.
  • Items sent to the Trash come back to their folder.
  • Tags that a drop added are removed again.

To undo one particular drop, open the drop log: View ▸ Show Drop Log (⇧⌘L). Each drop that can still be undone has an Undo button in its row, and a right-click on the row offers the same command. It undoes that one drop and leaves the later drops as they are. Only drops made since you opened BentoSort have the button, and after very many files older moves, Trash drops and tags-only drops lose it (see “Is there a limit to how many files I can drop?”).

Undo only touches the item the drop placed. If that file was replaced since (by a later drop, in Finder, or by an app that saved it again; many apps write a new file when they save), undo leaves it where it is and says “It was changed or replaced since this drop, so it was left where it is.”

When an undo could not reach a file because the disk is not connected or the file is locked, BentoSort names what is left (“Undo Move to Receipts was incomplete”), and the drop keeps its Undo button in the drop log: reconnect the disk and try again. ⌘Z goes on to the drop before.

Photos imports, shares and Open With App drops cannot be undone or redone. The Edit menu says so (“Can’t Undo …”), and ⌘Z and the toolbar’s Undo button cannot reach past such a drop; the drops before it keep their Undo buttons in the drop log.

To run an undone drop again, press ⇧⌘Z or choose Edit ▸ Redo; the menu names it, for example “Redo Move to Receipts”. Redo sends the files that drop actually placed through the box once more, with the same checks as the first time; files a stop, a skip or an error left alone stay where they are. It is offered after an undo that fully worked, for folder, Trash and tags-only drops of files from your Mac, not for items dragged from Mail, Safari or Photos. A new drop in the tray ends the chance to redo.

Deleting a box is a step in the same history. In Edit Mode, the minus at a box’s top left deletes it at once, without asking; ⌘Z (“Undo Delete Receipts”) brings it back with its settings and its folder, and ⇧⌘Z deletes it again. If another box took its cells meanwhile, it comes back in the first free cell. Delete Box… in the box settings asks first. A box deletion has no row in the drop log: only ⌘Z or the toolbar’s Undo button can undo it, and no longer after a Photos, share or Open With App drop in that tray.

What happens when a file with the same name is already there?

By default both are kept: the new one gets a number, such as “invoice 2.pdf”. In the box settings, under Name clash, you can choose instead: Ask (a sheet offers Keep Both, Replace or Skip, with “Apply to all”), Replace (the existing file goes to the Trash, so undo can bring it back) or Skip.

A box says “Offline”. What now?

The box’s folder is on a drive or network share that is not connected right now, for example a NAS share that is no longer mounted or a drive that is unplugged. The box is dimmed and shows “Offline: ” followed by the volume name, and it refuses drops, so no file goes anywhere by accident.

BentoSort checks a tray’s folders when the tray opens, each time you switch to BentoSort, and whenever macOS connects, disconnects or renames a drive or share; then a box shows “Offline” as soon as its drive is gone and works again when it is back. A share can also stop answering while macOS still counts it as connected. Then no notice comes, and a drop on the box fails with the reason; the files stay where they were.

For a network share, click Reconnect on the box. BentoSort asks macOS to mount the share again (macOS may ask for the password). If that does not work, the box names the share or volume to connect in Finder; then try again. For an external drive, plug it in; the box comes back when BentoSort becomes active again.

A box says “Waiting for a folder”.

The box has no folder on this Mac yet, so it refuses files (“Drop a folder or an app here to set up this box”). Click it and choose the folder, or drag that one folder from Finder onto the box: it becomes the box’s folder, and the box settings open. If BentoSort already knows which folder the box means (the example boxes, or a box from your other Mac), a drop on it also opens the folder panel, pointed at that folder. This happens for new boxes, and on a second Mac: see the next question.

I use BentoSort on two Macs. What syncs?

With the same Apple Account signed in to iCloud, your trays and boxes (names, grids, tray and box colors, icons including your own pictures, rules, and which folder each box points at) sync through your private iCloud database. Settings › iCloud shows the sync status.

Permission to use a folder does not travel: macOS grants it per Mac. On the second Mac, open a tray, choose File ▸ Link Folders…, then pick one parent folder, such as your home folder or the root of your NAS share. BentoSort links every box of that tray whose folder lies inside it and lists the boxes that still need a folder. Repeat for your other trays.

The drop log, window positions, the list of open windows and folder permissions stay on each Mac.

How do I give a tray to someone, or keep a backup?

File ▸ Export Tray… (⇧⌘E) saves the tray of the front window as a .bentosort file (Finder calls it a “BentoSort Tray”). Double-click it on any Mac with BentoSort, or use File ▸ Import… (⌘O). The import becomes a new tray in its own window. When it has folder boxes, Link Folders opens, so they can find their folders on that Mac.

The file contains the tray’s name, grid, color, window options, boxes and their settings, including the full paths of the folders the boxes point at. Keep that in mind before you send it to someone.

How does a Photos box work?

It adds the photos and videos you drop to your Photos library, or to an album you pick in the box settings. Other files are refused with “Not a photo or video.” A Photos box starts with Copy, so the original stays where it is. Set it to Move, and the original goes to the Trash after the import succeeded.

macOS asks once for Photos access: “add only” when the box has no album, or full access when you pick an album (BentoSort needs to list your albums for that). You can change this in System Settings › Privacy & Security › Photos. Photos imports cannot be undone in BentoSort; delete an import in Photos if needed.

Why do I have to click again when I drop on a Notes, Mail or AirDrop box?

A share box hands the files to the macOS sharing service you picked (the choice depends on what your Mac offers, typically Notes, Mail, AirDrop, Messages or Reminders). macOS then shows the service’s own window, and you finish there, for example by picking the AirDrop device or addressing the e-mail. BentoSort does not send anything by itself. Share boxes always leave the original in place.

How does an Open With App box work?

It opens what you drop with the app you chose, just like dropping the files on that app’s icon in the Dock. For example, PDFs into your PDF editor, or songs into Music (Music adds them to its library and plays them; the box settings offer Music as a one-click choice). If the app is not installed on a Mac, the box says so there.

Where is the drop log?

View ▸ Show Drop Log (⇧⌘L), or the log button in the toolbar. It lists each drop of the tray in the front window: time, box, what happened, the file names and the result. It keeps the last 1,000 drops per tray, on this Mac only. A drop made since you opened BentoSort has an Undo button in its row while it can still be undone.

Keyboard shortcuts
  • ⌘1 to ⌘9: switch the front window to another tray (in the order of Tray ▸ Manage Trays…)
  • ⌘N: new tray, in a new window; ⌘D: duplicate the tray
  • ⌘E: Edit Mode (move, resize and delete boxes)
  • Hold ⌥ or ⌘ while dropping: copy or move this once, whatever the box is set to
  • ⌘Z and ⇧⌘Z: undo a drop or a box deletion, and redo it
  • ⇧⌘T: keep the window above other apps
  • ⇧⌘L: drop log
  • ⌘O and ⇧⌘E: import a tray, and export the front one
Can the window stay in front while I work in Finder?

Yes. Switch on Always on Top (the pin in the toolbar, or Window ▸ Always on Top, ⇧⌘T). It is saved per tray. In the grid settings you can also let the window fade a little while another app is in front.

Can I see two trays at once?

Yes. Each tray can open in its own window: Tray ▸ Open in New Window, or the same item in the tray menu at the left of the toolbar. A tray is open in one window at most; choosing it again brings that window forward. ⌘1 to ⌘9 switch the front window to another tray.

Every tray keeps its own window size and position and its own Always on Top. Quit BentoSort (⌘Q) with its windows open and they all come back next time. Close the last window and BentoSort quits, once a running drop or undo has finished; next time it opens the tray you used last. The Dock icon’s menu lists your trays.

Can a tray have its own color?

Yes. Pick it when you create a tray, or later under Color in the Grid popover: Wood (the default: light wood, black lacquer in Dark Mode), Matcha, Sky, Vermilion, Indigo, Tamago, Salmon, Nori or Black Lacquer, or any color from the rainbow swatch. The tray’s frame, its grain, the dividers between the boxes and the thin lids on the boxes take the color. A dot in that color stands next to the tray’s name in the tray menu, the Tray menu and the Dock menu. The color syncs with the tray and goes along when you export or duplicate it.

Does BentoSort sort files on its own?

No. BentoSort is for sorting by hand: you drag each file onto a box yourself, and the box decides only where it lands and how (its folder or target, move or copy, name clashes, date subfolders, tags). BentoSort acts only on what you drop, and on Undo and Redo. It does not watch folders.

It never looks inside a file to decide anything: no text recognition, no dates read from documents, no AI. A box with date subfolders uses the date of the drop, or, if you choose so in its rules, the file’s creation date as macOS records it.

Which macOS version do I need?

macOS 26 or later.

Which languages does BentoSort speak?

59 languages and regional variants, among them English, German, French, Spanish, Japanese and Chinese. BentoSort follows the language you set for your Mac, or for BentoSort in System Settings › General › Language & Region.

How do I get a refund?

Purchases and refunds are handled by Apple. Request a refund at reportaproblem.apple.com.

Contact

The quickest way: in BentoSort, choose Help ▸ Contact Support…. It opens an e-mail to us with technical details already filled in: your Mac model, macOS and app version, language and region, iCloud sync status and whether you are signed in to iCloud, your settings, and how many trays, boxes and linked folders you have (never their names or folder paths). You see all of it before you send, and you can delete any part.

Or write to hello at bentosort dot app directly. Then it helps if you mention your macOS version and the BentoSort version.